Taisch newbie

Posts: 63 Join date: 2008-09-22
 | Subject: Attention All Students Tue Nov 11, 2008 9:41 am | |
| Whether you were for Obama or McCain, I think you should read this. http://www.whenshtf.com/showthread.php?t=6264If you don't feel like clicking the link and reading all the posts, here's the OP: | Quote: | Posted By:Cliff Mason CNBC Topics:Education | Barack Obama | Stock Market Friday, 7 Nov 2008
If there's one part of the coming Obama Presidency that I'm not looking forward to, it's his "voluntary" but also "universal" national service plan.
Some of this stuff is unobjectionable: expanding AmeriCorps, and doubling the size of the Peace Corps. But then there's the mandatory part of his voluntary service scheme, and here I'll let the Obama-Biden web site speak for itself: "Obama and Biden will set a goal that all middle and high school students do 50 hours of community service a year. They will develop national guidelines for service-learning and will give schools better tools both to develop programs and to document student experience."
Putting aside the question of the educational value of community service, there's simply nothing voluntary about forcing middle and high school students to do 50 hours of community service a year. Obama may have carried the youth vote, voters between the ages of 18 and 29, by a 66 to 32 margin, but I bet if kids in middle and high school could vote and they knew about Obama's plan to conscript them into this national community service program, his margin among that age group would have been a lot slimmer although he still would've won handily because the Republicans, thanks to their intransigence on social issues, have lost an entire generation of voters, but more on that in another post.
Middle school and high school were bad enough without having to do hundreds of hours of community service. I can only hope that this sort of thing won't get through Congress, and just this once I'm thankful that education policy is handled primarily at the state and local level. And as ever, I'm glad that I'm no longer a student.
Obama's web site also suggests that he'll "require 100 hours of service in college," another frightening prospect, but there's some ambiguity here because it seems as though this might be truly voluntary community service that you would do in exchange for a $4,000 tax credit. If it is mandatory, I suggest all college students try to graduate as fast possible, before this has a chance to become the law of the land.
As far as I'm concerned, this is yet another attack on the young by the political class. Obama's clearly a brilliant man, but how can he be so stupid when it comes to national service? You can't teach American kids civics by forcing them to do community service work. We're stubborn, in fact, that's our singular national virtue. For a guy who spends so much time decrying cynicism, he sure seems to be pushing a program that will make the next generation even more cynical than me and my millennial buddies, and we're a tough act to follow. Call me a skeptic, but this "Ve haf vays of making you serve" program just doesn't seem like the kind of thing that encourages civic-mindedness. In general, coercion doesn't tend to produce good results.
Here's to hoping that "national service" itself was a cynical ploy on Obama's part and he'll forget all about once he takes office. Hey, Mr. President, leave those kids alone! |
Alot of reading, sure, but it's just something you all might want to think about. _________________ I am going to become rich and famous when I invent a device that allows me to stab people in the face over the internet.
|
|
CharleyNovember newbie

Posts: 64 Join date: 2008-09-26
 | |
Taisch newbie

Posts: 63 Join date: 2008-09-22
 | Subject: Re: Attention All Students Tue Nov 11, 2008 6:58 pm | |
| Screw that. If I want a new uniform I'll just run down to the local Army/Navy store. Or just wait for 3 months until I get to bootcamp. _________________ I am going to become rich and famous when I invent a device that allows me to stab people in the face over the internet.
|
|
Ethre_Jade newbie

Posts: 2 Join date: 2008-11-09 Location: Tusc.
 | Subject: Re: Attention All Students Wed Nov 12, 2008 2:28 pm | |
|
All I keep hearing is money, money, services, services, money - with no mention of how its going to be paid for (came from both sides). |
|
StarWars Sergent


Posts: 669 Join date: 2008-09-22 Age: 16 Location: Arab Alabama
 | Subject: Re: Attention All Students Wed Nov 12, 2008 4:30 pm | |
| This might do us kids some good. Maybe set this generation back on the right path. Im up for it. |
|
OminousAssassin Steel City Airsoft Member


Posts: 211 Join date: 2008-09-23 Age: 18 Location: birmingham
 | Subject: Re: Attention All Students Thu Nov 13, 2008 4:42 am | |
| it all depends on how they go about it.. but we voted for fail  |
|
Taisch newbie

Posts: 63 Join date: 2008-09-22
 | Subject: Re: Attention All Students Thu Nov 13, 2008 8:21 am | |
| I for one am against it. Of course, I didn't vote for Obama Bin Laden anyway, but you know. Comrade SW, forcing kids into slave labor like that isn't going to set anyone straight. The best it'll do is create animosity. The morale alone would be noticable - you'd see a marked difference in the attitudes between people that want to be there and do their community good, and people who don't want to be there. On top of that, he plans to double the hour load for college students? He's obviously never gone to college, otherwise he'd know most of us have enough shit on our hands between term papers, exams out the ass, and other assignments - we don't need some idiot telling us we have to go out and "do the community a favor or else." _________________ I am going to become rich and famous when I invent a device that allows me to stab people in the face over the internet.
|
|